Every once in a while you read something that so perfectly encapsulates your feelings on a subject you wonder how the writer can be in such synchronicity with you. That is the case with
Thomas Friedman's column today in the New York Times.
Mr. Friedman argues that we should not build up the troop levels in Afghanistan because we cannot want victory there than its citizens. He thinks it's time to reduce our presence and re-think our goals. That perhaps if everyone there had to stand on their own they would reconsider the actions they are taking. In his words, "Let them all start paying retail for their extremism, not wholesale. Then you’ll see movement."
From the piece:
What if we shrink our presence in Afghanistan? Won’t Al Qaeda return, the
Taliban be energized and Pakistan collapse? Maybe. Maybe not. This gets to my
second principle: In the Middle East, all politics — everything that matters —
happens the morning after the morning after. Be patient. Yes, the morning after
we shrink down in Afghanistan, the Taliban will celebrate, Pakistan will quake
and bin Laden will issue an exultant video.
And the morning after the morning after, the Taliban factions will
start fighting each other, the Pakistani Army will have to destroy their
Taliban, or be destroyed by them, Afghanistan’s warlords will carve up the
country, and, if bin Laden comes out of his cave, he’ll get zapped by a
drone.
He has a point. The presence of our forces are driving people to act like the Taliban even if they aren't joining the Taliban. They want the foreign invaders gone. The
Karzai government only wants us in the country to prop themselves up. If people want democracy they need to work for it and earn it like every other democracy. We cannot keep spilling blood and spending ourselves broke to enforce our will on a country that doesn't seem interested in our way of doing things.
So we should just go.
I hope President Obama is taking so much time to make a decision on Afghanistan because he is considering this option. The United States needs its young people and money right now. This isn't "losing", no matter what the Fox News crowd thinks. This is cutting ourselves loose from a bad deal. I hope the president is smart enough to see this for himself.